SMC’s Hollow Development Exposed: Crores Spent, Structures Crumbling Across Surat

Surat | Gujarat — The collapse of a water tank during testing in Tadkeshwar has ripped the mask off Surat Municipal Corporation’s much-touted “development model”. What should have been a routine safety check instead turned into a chilling reminder of how fragile public infrastructure has become under SMC’s watch. The incident has triggered widespread anger, exposing a disturbing pattern of substandard construction, alleged corruption and complete absence of accountability across Surat — particularly in the Vadod zone.

For a city that prides itself on speed, growth and glossy infrastructure claims, the reality on the ground tells a far uglier story. Government constructions built with public money worth crores are collapsing, cracking or leaking within just seven to ten years — while private homes built by ordinary citizens often stand firm for 40 to 50 years. The obvious question now echoing across Surat is: Is this development real, or just hollow concrete waiting to fall?

One of the most alarming examples is the 15 lakh litre overhead water tank constructed in 2015 under TP Scheme-71 in Vadod area. Barely a decade old, the tank is today in a dangerous condition. Cement layers have peeled off on all four sides, steel rods are fully exposed, and water is leaking continuously, accelerating corrosion. Even the staircase leading to the top is so weak that residents fear stepping on it.

Locals warn that if this tank collapses, densely populated residential areas around it could face massive loss of life and property. “Repairs are done only as fire-fighting measures. No one is held responsible for the poor original construction,” a resident said, questioning who will be accountable if disaster strikes.

The rot does not stop there. Shri Bipin Chandra Ramchandra Pal School (School No. 199) in Vadod Awas, Udhna zone, built just ten years ago, has developed deep cracks in its walls. Cement plaster is falling off, water leaks from the roof, and iron angles had to be installed to prevent slabs from collapsing. A government school meant to nurture children has instead become a daily safety hazard — a damning indictment of the system.

Equally shocking is the fate of the Vadod Health Centre, built in 2014 and shut down by 2020 due to severe structural deterioration. The condition was so bad that SMC was forced to file a case against the contractor. A public health facility collapsing within six years stands as one of the strongest proofs of corruption and negligence.

The Vadod garden wall, constructed in 2014, collapsed within six months and remains unrepaired even today. Located along a busy road, it poses a constant threat to pedestrians and motorists. Inside the garden, paver blocks and toilets also deteriorated within six years — turning “development” into a cruel joke.

Former Congress corporator Bharatibehn Tiwari did not mince words. “The Mangrol water tank collapse is not an accident, it is institutional corruption,” she said. “For the last ten years, a commission culture has ruled Surat Municipal Corporation. Contractors are given free hand, complaints are ignored, and structures are built that cannot survive even a decade. When I raised these issues repeatedly, my complaints fell on deaf ears.”

From Tadkeshwar to Vadod zone, the pattern is identical: hurried work, poor-quality materials, irresponsible contractors and cosmetic repairs instead of punishment.